Over its almost 185 year existence, FPC's primary place of worship has been the building at 128 East Main Street in Lebanon IN. However, there have been other properties serving various functions, over the years. These are documneted here.

In 1853, 13 years after its founding, FPC built its first church building, on East Street, on a lot where the old Baptist Church is located today. In 1872, FPC sold that building to a short-lived second Presbyterian Church in Lebanon, the First United Presbyterian Church. Three years later, that FUPC church sold the building to the Baptists and shortly after, disbanded.

In 1901, property for a manse or parsonage was obtained and for the next 50 to 60 years, it served as the residence of the FPC pastor and family. FPC sold that property in 1961 and no longer has a parsonage property.

In 1954, needing additional Sunday School and other classroom space, FPC rented an apartment building across East St and used it for supplemental classroom space, until it built the new west classroom annex in 1968.